Lima, Peru  |  Wednesday 10 March 2010 19:10  |  |  | 

There's not a question for this week


Politics | 29 December, 2009 [ 23:39 ]

Peru: Official report on Bagua clashes creates controversy


LivinginPeru.com
Isabel Guerra

The final report issued by an official commission that investigated on the death of 23 police officers and 10 civilians in Bagua, in theAmazonas region, has generated disagreements among the commission members, and the natives' representatives refused to sign it because they think it is biased.

The investigative commision concludes that the violent clashes that caused those deaths “are attributable to” the indigenous, lawmakers of the Partido Nacionalista (Nationalist Party), the national teachers' union (Sutep), radio reporters and “governmental tactlessness.”

The final text also claims that some members of religious orders were biased to the indigenous.

The report has been signed by former ministers Susana Pinilla and Pilar Mazzetti, former government official Manuel Bernales and the Dominican missionary Ricardo Alvarez.

The document does not give any clarification on which governmental authority ordered the police squads to remove the protestors that had been blocking a sector of the road, an action that generated the clashes that took 33 lives according to official figures.

The natives' representative Jesús Manacés and the Spanish nun María Gómez refused to sign the document, and sent the government a letter with “43 observations of disagreement.”

Manacés told the international press that “the commission has not determined any responsibilities, and the final conclusions do not reflect the real facts that took place last Jun. 5.”

The official debate on this official report has been delayed for Jan. 12.

Have news you'd like to see in LivinginPeru.com? Contribute an article, whether it's translated or based on your own reporting. Contact editor@livinginperu.com.

 | digg it! | StumbleUpon | |

2 Comments

# wow says :
30 December, 2009 [ 07:04 ]

LIP why did you choose to show just a photo of police grabbing a native and not the natives with dead police? Lets show some balance in reporting. also i noticed last time you didnt publish my last comment critizing your left leaning reporting. Give us the news unslanted

# Lizardo A.Lopez says :
3 January, 2010 [ 09:14 ]

We will continue to have this same discussion over and over, until we do not institutionalize, that members of an investigation committee should be chosen by ballots or an impartial election. Never and I mean NEVER include members of a political party or government member.  Maybe it’s just some kind of dream or illusion I have but it would be the only way.

Add your comment
Name

Email

Notify me via e-mail of new comments to this entry


Code :


Comment

  • Comments are the property of their respective authors, and LivinginPeru.com is not responsible for the content of these comments
  • Only comments in English will be published
  • Por ahora solo se permiten comentarios en ingles.
  • Any offensive, injurious, profane or disrespectful comments will not be published
  • You must include a real email address (this WILL be verified) for your comments to be published
  • Repeat comments, or comments of a similar nature written by the same person will not be published
  • All comments are sent to a moderator before publication
  • Referring to the topic indicated in the article will increase your chances of publication
  • Repeat offenses of the above guidelines will result in the removal of your ability to comment

 

News Sections (Archive)

  1. BREAKING NEWS! (76)
  2. Top (206)
  3. Peru (1983)
  4. Lima (710)
  5. Latin America (194)
  6. World (265)
  7. Politics (878)
  8. Elections 2006 (172)
  9. Economy (800)
  10. Business (716)
  11. Sports (645)
  12. Law and Order (844)
  13. Health (345)
  14. Travel and Tourism (492)
  15. Art/Culture/History (289)
  16. Education (117)
  17. Environment/Nature (217)
  18. TV/Entertainment (395)
  19. Tech / Internet (104)
  20. Press Releases (146)
  21. Dossiers (2)
  22. Opinion (14)
  23. Kids (32)
  24. Photo of the day (286)
  25. Advice (63)
  26. Announcements (60)
  27. Mining/Energy (361)
  28. Agriculture (59)
  29. Transportation (266)
  30. Natural Disasters (150)
  31. Communications (50)
  32. APEC PERU 2008 (225)
  33. EU-LAC Peru 2008 (70)
  34. Science (14)
  35. Fashion (9)
  36. Food (118)
  37. Celebrities (35)

Last 5 news articles

Last comments

See all comments

News web syndication [RSS]
what is "web syndication" ?